Customer Service 1 (888) 261-2693
Please enter Search keyword. Advanced Search

The World's Most Successful Depression-Era Investor

By Chris Mayer, editor, Capital & Crisis
Saturday, December 6, 2008

You probably know John Maynard Keynes as an economist, but may not know that he was also a great investor, maybe the most the successful of the Great Depression era. And for that reason, given all that our own markets are going through, it may be a good time to look at his investment career.

Keynes managed Cambridge's King's College Chest Fund. The Fund averaged 12% per year from 1927-1946, which was remarkable given that the period seemed to be all about gray skies and storm clouds – it included the Great Depression and World War II. The U.K. stock market fell 15% during this stretch. And to top it off, the Chest Fund's returns included only capital appreciation, as the college spent the income earned in the portfolio, which was considerable. I think it must be one of the most remarkable track records in the annals of finance. 

Keynes also made himself a personal fortune as an investor. When he died, he left an estate worth some $30 million in present-day dollars, which surprised his contemporaries. How he did it is the subject of this essay. A new book by Justyn Walsh, Keynes and the Market, is our chief guide on the subject.

Keynes began as a run-of-mill speculator and trader, trying to anticipate trends and forecast cycles. The Great Crash of 1929 sent him back to the drawing board.

Keynes was, in fact, nearly wiped out in the Great Crash. His personal net worth fell by more than 80%. He then had a great conversion. Trading the market demanded "abnormal foresight" and "phenomenal skill" to work, he concluded. "I am clear," the new Keynes wrote in a memorandum, "that the idea of wholesale shifts [in and out of the market at different stages of the business cycle] is for various reasons impracticable and undesirable."

After the crash, he became an investor, rather than a speculator. His new ideas on investing began to presage those of value investing icons Ben Graham and Warren Buffett.

Keynes now focused less on forecasting the market. Instead, he cast his keen mind on individual securities, trying to figure out their "ultimate values," as he called them. He summed up his new philosophy in a note to a colleague: "My purpose is to buy securities where I am satisfied as to assets and ultimate earnings power and where the market price seems cheap in relation to these."

He also became more patient. Paraphrasing from his own analogy, Keynes described how it was easier and safer in the long run to buy a 75-cent dollar and wait, rather than buy a 75-cent dollar and sell it because it became a 50-cent dollar – and hope to buy it back as a 40-cent dollar. Keynes learned to trust more in his own research and opinions, and not let market prices put him off a good deal. 

Keynes developed a fierce contrarian streak. One of his greatest personal coups came in 1933. The Great Depression was on. Franklin Delano Roosevelt's speeches gushed with anti-corporate rhetoric. The market sank. America's utilities were, Keynes noticed, extremely cheap in "what is for the time being an irrationally unfashionable market." He bought the depressed preferred stocks. In the next year, his personal net worth would nearly triple.

In a note, Keynes laid out his understanding of the quirky, contrarian nature of investing. It is "the one sphere of life and activity where victory, security and success is always to the minority, and never to the majority. When you find anyone agreeing with you, change your mind."

He also learned to hold on to his stocks "through thick and thin," he said, to let the magic of compounding do its thing. (In a tax-free fashion, too, by avoiding capital gains taxes.) "'Be quiet' is our best motto," he wrote, by which he meant to ignore the short-term noise and let the longer-term forces assert themselves. It also meant limiting his activities to buying only when he found intrinsic values far above stock prices.

Keynes came to the conclusion that you could own too many stocks. Better to own fewer stocks and more of your very best ideas than spread yourself too thin. At times during Keynes' career, half of his portfolio might be in only a handful of names, though he liked to mix up the risks he took. So though five names might make up half of his portfolio, they wouldn't be all gold stocks, for instance. "For his faith in portfolio concentration," Walsh writes, "Keynes was rewarded with an investment performance far superior – albeit more volatile – than that of the broader market."

In the depth of the Depression, Keynes lost a friend, Sidney Russell Cooke, who took his own life after suffering severe losses in the market. Keynes, perhaps reflecting on this experience, wrote that investors need to take losses with "as much equanimity and patience" as possible. Investors must accept that stock prices can swing wide of underlying values for extended stretches of time.

Keynes' investment performance improved markedly after adopting these ideas. Whereas in the 1920s, he generally trailed the market, he was a great performer after the crash. From 1931 to 1945, the Chest Fund rose 10-fold in value in 15 years, versus no return for the overall market. That is a truly awesome performance in an awfully tough environment.

Good investing,


P.S. As investors wonder whether we face a 1930s-style market or not, I found Walsh's review of Keynes' investing career useful and inspirational. The more I study investing, the more this same handful of ideas and principles seems to recur. You can find Walsh's book, Keynes and the Market, on Amazon.

Editor's note: Chris Mayer is the editor of Capital & Crisis, a monthly advisory we consider required reading at DailyWealth. With Chris' research, you can always count on contrarian investment ideas you won't read about anywhere else.

Click here to learn more about Capital & Crisis and how Chris has compiled one of the most amazing track records in the business. We think a subscription is one of the best investment deals available today. 

Market Notes


From the "no duh" files this week: The government says the U.S. economy is in recession.

As we've pointed out many times this year, our "armchair economist" indicators have beenpointing and screaming that the economy is in trouble.

This week, the government made it official. But anyone looking at the 55% decline in copper was already saying, "You bet your life we're in a recession!"

– Brian Hunt

Recent Articles

  • House Prices to Soar AFTER the Fed Raises Rates
    By Dr. Steve Sjuggerud
    Friday, August 29, 2014

    Yes, the Federal Reserve should raise interest rates next year. But no, that does not mean that the housing market is doomed.
    In fact, the opposite is true, based on history...

  • What the 9th Inning of This Bull Market Will Look Like
    By Dr. Steve Sjuggerud
    Thursday, August 28, 2014

    This was the first time I'd experienced "The Ninth Inning" of a major stock market boom. I sure got the full experience...

  • Why Stocks Should Run Higher From Here
    By Brett Eversole
    Wednesday, August 27, 2014

    Right now, a stock market extreme is pointing to higher stock prices from here...

  • When It's Okay NOT to Listen
    By Dr. Steve Sjuggerud
    Tuesday, August 26, 2014

    How can you be at the top of your game if you don't even know what the top of your game looks like right now? If you don't even know what your peers are doing?

  • "Non-Reportable" Gold
    By Dr. Steve Sjuggerud
    Monday, August 25, 2014

    "If I hold gold at a bank in Switzerland, is that reportable to the IRS?" That little question sure kicked open a can of worms...